posts — Page 20 — Andy James

No Other Comfort

July 6, 2014 By Andy James

a sermon on Matthew 11:16-19, 25-30
preached on July 6, 2014, at the First Presbyterian Church of Whitestone

Amidst all the discussion and celebration of independence this weekend, the Times offered an interesting look at the changes to feelings of national pride over the course of several generations. They highlighted a recent survey that showed that young adults—roughly defined as people younger than me—have less interest in supporting the symbols of American democracy while showing a higher level of respect for “classic American ideals like equality and opportunity.” Most notably, the article notes a consistent decline in the percentage of Americans who “consider their American identity to be extremely important,” ranging from 78% of the oldest generation among us to 70% of baby boomers, 60% of “Generation X”ers, and now only 45% of young adults. The article looked closely at broader trends for other generations over time and on this basis suggested that this is a long-term trend that will not change as this youngest generation grows older. However, while this youngest generation may not wave the flag or “love America” quite as much as those who are a bit older, their attention to the values that define our union makes it clear that they can’t be considered any less patriotic than anyone else.

Now, you might wonder, what does this news about patriotism have to do with our strange story from Matthew’s gospel this morning? Well, I think Jesus was facing a time where people were focused on the symbols of his ministry and missing the values that stood behind it. He was about halfway through his recorded ministry and had gone so far as to commission his disciples to go out and do some of the work that he had been doing, so he stepped back to assess how things had gone. He was even challenged by his old friend and preacher John the Baptist, now stuck in prison, to send him back an assessment.

When Jesus looked around, though, he saw a bunch of people who loved the spectacle and symbols of what he was doing but who totally missed the point of why he was doing it. He saw people who loved his miracles, who listened carefully to every word of his teaching and preaching, who followed him around from town to town, who brought their sick friends and family to him in hopes of finding healing—but who ultimately missed the point of it all. The people loved the symbolism of what he was doing, but they didn’t really seem to understand the values behind it, the reality that following this message had consequences.

So Jesus voiced his frustrations with them, about lifting up his voice and not being heard, about offering his hope and finding vindication only in the long term, about revealing his wisdom to the wise only to have them dismiss it as folly. The worst of Jesus’ frustration actually comes in the verses that our reading from the lectionary skips, where he reproached the cities where he had been preaching and teaching and healing for ignoring his cries to repent. He didn’t seem to be frustrated so much by their personal sinfulness or lack of traditional morality but by the ways in which they seemed to be focused on all the wrong things. Jesus lamented how deeply astray this entire generation seemed to be, how they were unable to tear their minds and hearts away from themselves, how they insisted upon status and privilege for themselves, how they missed all the ways in which God’s kingdom was being revealed in their midst through not just deeds of power but even more through the dancing and weeping led by the children, the poor, the needy, the widow, the orphan, all those for whom God shows special care and concern because the world so easily forgets them along the way.

After voicing his frustration at the people’s inability to take his message to heart, Jesus turned his focus to prayer. He invited the people—and us—to overhear his prayer to God, a prayer not about changing hearts and minds or convincing anyone that he has a better way but rather a word of thanksgiving for the people who did seem to be getting it, for the ways in which God was hiding these lessons from those who claimed to be wise and instead revealing it to “infants”—not literally babies but children in spirit who were willing to start fresh and be open to the fullness of what God was doing in the world. Jesus thanked God for keeping this message from being so clear to some people, for letting him keep his focus on those truly in need, for welcoming not those who were already at home but those who needed a place to settle in for good.

In his frustration and in his prayer, Jesus was embodying the deep and clear biblical message so well expressed by twentieth-century Reformed theologian Karl Barth,

that righteousness always requires favoring the “threatened innocent, the oppressed poor, widow, orphans, and aliens… God always stands unconditionally and passionately on this side and on this side alone: against the lofty and on behalf of the lowly; against those who already enjoy right and privilege and on behalf of those who are denied and deprived of it.” (Karl Barth, Church Dogmatics, II/1, p. 386; quoted by William Goettler in “Pastoral Perspective on Matthew 11:16-19, 25-30,” Feasting on the Word: Year A Volume 3, p. 214.)

Jesus was frustrated with a world that was so focused on preserving the symbols of everything that it didn’t care about the people in greatest need—and most of all didn’t care that it didn’t care.

As we celebrate the independence of our nation this weekend, it seems like a good and fair moment to think a bit about these things, about our care and concern for those in greatest need, about our attention to the transformation of the world that requires us to give up our power and privilege for the sake of others, about the challenge from our young adults to pay attention to the values that define us rather than the symbols that stand before us.

It is easy to forget that Jesus was a young adult in his day, certainly in a slightly different category than he might be today because of substantially shorter life expectancies but still also likely to have been dismissed and derided as one whose attitudes and behaviors would change as he grew older. Yet his insistence on caring for the poor, on breaking down the structures of power that preserved the status quo, and on building up a new way of life that focused on the fullness of life for all are so very similar to those values of equality and fairness that are lifted up by young adults in our own day and age. To put numbers on it, the survey cited by the Times notes that some 37% of the oldest generation think that unequal chances in life are a big problem while 57% of young adults call that inequality a big issue. I think Jesus would welcome this kind of reassessment that helps us to focus anew on the values that lay behind our symbols and that invite us to recognize how we can be more faithful in our life together.

Then it is in these moments, these times when we have faithfully considered how God is calling us to live in gracious mercy toward all, these places where we have given up our power and privilege to trust God’s presence with us, when we can begin to claim those hopeful words that close our text for today. These beautiful words echo across the ages:

Come to me, all you that are weary and are carrying heavy burdens, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn from me; for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light.

When we hear these words alongside this call to deeper repentance, it becomes clear that Jesus offers rest and comfort not to those who already enjoy it but to those who are most in need of it, to those who have no power to make it happen for themselves, “to those who have been made weary by a world that fails to comprehend the burden of injustice.” (William Goettler)

So Jesus calls us to set aside our hopes in our own salvation, our trust in other understandings of the world, our confidence in military might, our allegiance to flags and nations, our hope in the power of the world—everything that yokes us to things other than him—so that we might know this kind of true rest, this sort of easy yoke and light burden, this freedom that comes only from God in Jesus Christ our Lord. When we do this, we need no other comfort than what we find in Jesus Christ our Lord. We need no other sign than the cross. And we need no other goal in our life together than to seek the promise of love and joy and peace for all people in the new thing that God is doing in our world.

So may God strengthen us as to open our hearts and minds to this deeper and truer comfort, this most hopeful sign, and this most joyous goal, until all things are made new. Thanks be to God. Amen.

An Ending and A Beginning

June 30, 2014 By Andy James

a sermon on Philippians 1:1-11
preached on June 29, 2014, for the retirement of Rev. Jane Donnelly

One of the most immediately surprising things about the letters of the apostle Paul to our modern ears is that he seems to get his beginnings and endings all mixed up. Nowadays, whether they be for business or for pleasure, whether sent as email, typed and printed, or handwritten, we sign our letters at the end, not at the beginning. So to hear Paul’s name first, even before the names of the people he is addressing in his letter, throws me off a bit. But when you get down to it, it’s a perfect situation for a day like today, this day when we celebrate a particular ending in the life and ministry of our friend and colleague and pastor Jane, because the end is the beginning and the beginning is the end.

Jane and I are separated by just a few years of age—I think I counted it up once, and it seems like it might have been six or seven years between us!—but we had the privilege of beginning our ministries as pastors within just a few months of one another. Though we did not know each other before I moved to New York City in 2005, it has been a real honor to journey together over the past nine years, attending the Early Ministry Institute, working as members of the presbytery’s Committee on Preparation for Ministry, sharing our stories and wisdom in our pastoral reflection group, and spending many holidays in her home when I couldn’t be with my own family. As much as we began together, it is now an incredible privilege for me to be a part of this ending—this ending that like those in Paul’s letters is mixed up with a new beginning.

After we get beyond his mixed-up beginning and ending, Paul’s letter to the Philippians offers us three incredible and important messages for this day of beginnings and endings. First, he offers us the theme of thanksgiving and joy. The whole letter to the Philippians is filled with expressions of these wonderful gifts, and it is right and good that all our beginnings and endings be filled with them, too. Paul has much to be thankful for here: the faithful witness of the Philippians; the hope that they share through the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ; and the gift of these sisters and brothers holding him in their hearts amidst his struggles and imprisonment. His thanksgiving, then, overflows into joy—joy that lifts his heart, joy that sustains him in the midst of the challenges that he faces, joy that fills his prayers each and every day.

Those prayers are the second theme that inform this ending and beginning for us today. In his greeting to the Philippians, Paul makes it clear that his distance from them has not kept him from holding them in prayer. For Paul, prayer is the key way of maintaining his relationship with the Philippians when he cannot remain present with them. In his prayers, he offers thanksgiving for their faithful witness. He prays for love to be continually shared with him and others. And he prays that they might emerge from the trials and tribulations of the life of faith “pure and blameless, having produced the harvest of righteousness that comes through Jesus Christ for the glory and praise of God.” Any distance, then, that emerges for us today because of this ending and this beginning is made so much less because we know that we will keep one another in prayer.

So as we approach this ending and beginning today, Paul offers us one final important reminder by lifting up the importance of the end. Paul isn’t particularly known for extended reflection on the end times, but he never leaves that idea totally behind. Here he twice reminds the Philippians that they are not just looking at each day ahead—they are ultimately looking toward “the day of Jesus Christ.” His thanksgiving and his prayers are all focused on this goal ahead, on the work that God is doing in the Philippians that God will finish before the end, on the wholeness and completeness that God will bring into being as the end brings with it a new beginning. So Paul encourages the Philippians too to keep their focus on this bigger goal, not just to keep things going as they are now until the end comes but seeking every day to be a part of the new beginning, the “harvest of righteousness,” that God is bringing through Jesus Christ.

So this strange mix of endings and beginnings from Paul, shaped by thanksgiving, prayer, and an even bigger ending, seems all too fitting for today. This day seems like the perfect embodiment of the beautiful words of T.S. Eliot:

What we call the beginning is often the end
And to make an end is to make a beginning.
The end is where we start from.

As we celebrate the ending of this phase of ministry for Jane and Bay Ridge United Church today, we know that the past nine years have been shaped by all these things, by deep thanksgiving for faithful witness, by prayer for continued faithfulness and shared grace, and by hope for an even bigger ending and an even greater beginning. But as Eliot says, this end is the start of our new beginning together—a continuation of the new things happening in the life of Bay Ridge United and Fourth Avenue churches, a next step in the ministry of our friend, colleague, and pastor Jane, a new beginning for all of us as we journey together with all our sisters and brothers in this time of change and transition, this end and beginning that show us how God has been at work around us and open us to how God will continue to make all things new in our world.

While we may not know the fullness of what is ahead for Jane, for these two churches, or for any of us, Paul’s thanksgiving, Paul’s prayers, and Paul’s hopes for God’s new creation ahead remind us that we walk together, always carrying these gifts from these beautiful words with us along the journey. Again, I think the words of T.S. Eliot offer a glorious reminder of the hope and prayer that are ours in the days ahead:

With the drawing of this Love and the voice of this Calling

We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time.
Through the unknown, unremembered gate
When the last of earth left to discover
Is that which was the beginning;
At the source of the longest river
The voice of the hidden waterfall
And the children in the apple-tree
Not known, because not looked for
But heard, half-heard, in the stillness
Between two waves of the sea.
Quick now, here, now, always—
A condition of complete simplicity
(Costing not less than everything)
And all shall be well and
All manner of thing shall be well
When the tongues of flames are in-folded
Into the crowned knot of fire
And the fire and the rose are one. (“Little Gidding,” from Four Quartets)

So on this day of strange endings and beginnings, may God’s presence sustain us on the journey ahead, may God’s grace surprise us in all our exploration, and may God’s love surround us at all our endings and all our beginnings as all things are made new in Jesus Christ our Lord. Thanks be to God! Amen.

A Two-Way Welcome

June 29, 2014 By Andy James

a sermon on Matthew 10:40-42
preached on June 29, 2014, at the First Presbyterian Church of Whitestone

There is truly something wonderful in that short song that we just sang—and not just because I managed to get you all singing in parts a little! Like so many songs from around the world that are coming into our knowledge nowadays, this song comes bearing a story. Even though you can now find it our hymnal, it was collected only a few years ago in South Africa by the Scottish pastor and songwriter John Bell. It comes out of a hospice program for those suffering from HIV/AIDS in South Africa, a program that steps into the gap for those who have been abandoned by friends and family as they deal with this dreadful and incurable disease, a program that responds to such a disease in a place where the lasting effects of poverty and apartheid are still prominent. These people have every reason to question the depth and breadth of God’s loving welcome, and yet still they sing joyfully and hopefully, trusting God’s amazing love to carry them through the difficulties of their disease and welcome them into new life.

This kind of wildly inclusive welcome despite every reason to think and act otherwise stands at the core of what Jesus was describing in our reading from Matthew’s gospel this morning. Jesus had been preparing his disciples for their first mission work in his name, and he was about to send them out on their own to share his teachings, heal the sick, and proclaim the coming of the kingdom of God. He had told them where to go (the people of Israel, not the Samaritans or Gentiles), what to say (“The kingdom of heaven has come near”), what attitude to offer in the face of opposition (have no fear of it), what to leave behind (family and friends and commitments at home), and what to take with them (nothing other than a cross as they followed him).

But then he offered these words from our reading today to close his instructions, telling his disciples not about how they needed to treat others along their way but about the blessing would emerge through them for those who met them along the way. Jesus insisted that his disciples were extensions of him, that any welcome offered to them was welcome offered to him, that God’s reward for the prophets and the righteous extended to those who welcomed prophets and the righteous like them, that care and concern offered to anyone, even a glass of water shared with those who might be looked down upon by society, was ultimately offered to Jesus himself. Without their even knowing it, those who chose to receive the disciples would offer the presence of God to them—and in so doing receive that presence for themselves.

This two-way welcome—the welcome that God offers to us that we proclaimed in our song a few minutes ago and the welcome that we offer to others and so offer back to God—is a critical part of what it means to be church in these days. In a day and age when an increasing number of people have never experienced church for themselves, when God’s welcome so often does not reach people who do not seek it out, when the words of the Bible are still so often used to offer hope to the insider at the exclusion of the outsider, when Sundays are more likely to be spent sipping a latte and reading the newspaper than sitting in a sanctuary, this two-way welcome is more important than ever to show the world what God’s welcome looks like—and to open our eyes to how the world is showing that welcome to us, too.

This two-way welcome is most easily seen in the hospitality we offer to others in our life as the church. Over my nearly nine years here serving as your pastor, we have talked several times about how we do this—how we greet everyone, members and visitors alike, as we arrive for worship; how we work to honor the image of God in everyone who crosses our path; how we offer time and space for those who make their way here to discover God’s welcome within and beyond these walls. But we do this in other ways, too—in our openness in our life to new ideas and different patterns of life together in the church community, in our willingness to embrace the fullness of the lives of those who journey with us, even in our standing with and speaking out for others who cannot do so on their own.

But the two-way welcome that Jesus offers us here is not just about offering God’s welcome to others—it is also about being open to receive that same welcome from others, too. It’s easy for us to think that we need to be good at offering a welcome to others, but Jesus’ message to the disciples here ultimately challenges them to accept the welcome given to them and to trust that it is not just extended to them but to God too. This two-way welcome reminds us that when we offer hospitality at its best, we find ourselves both giving and receiving, for we find that just when we think we are most prepared to host, we are actually becoming the guest. When we think that we have offered enough of a welcome to others, they turn around and show us the same gift. And when we are confident that God’s welcome has reached its limit, God will remind us again in those we have welcomed before, “Whoever welcomes you welcomes me, and whoever welcomes me welcomes the one who sent me.”

This afternoon, several dozen Presbyterians will gather on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan, in front of First Presbyterian Church, to offer a ministry of welcome to the marchers in the annual New York City Pride Parade. As women and men stream down Fifth Avenue to celebrate the unique culture and community of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender persons, these faithful Presbyterians and friends will offer cookies, hugs, and even a cup of cold water to marchers of any and every sort. They’ve been doing this for four or five years now, seeking to extend God’s welcome to each and every person. They’re taking these words of Jesus quite literally, not because of any earthly or heavenly reward, not even expecting to convince some of the marchers to show up at church next Sunday, but because it is the kind of welcome that Jesus himself would offer. As I’ve listened to the stories of friends and colleagues who have shared in this ministry over the years, I’ve heard that this has been a two-way welcome, that they have received as much welcome as they have shared, that their offering of even this simple cup of cold water has broken down barriers, that the transformation that is possible through God’s amazing grace shines here in new and glorious ways, not just to the people who receive this gift of water but even more to the people who step out and share it.

Now while it may not be as easy for us to stand out in front of our church and offer a cup of water to in this way, while we may not be in a place to directly hear the stories of people whose songs can embody an incredible sense of welcome and grace and hope, God still challenges us to offer and receive this kind of welcome in our lives of faith. We can find times and places and ways to share that cup of cold water with those who are thirsty. We can look for other opportunities to speak up for those who cannot speak for themselves. And we can offer the fullness of God’s welcome to strangers and friends, trusting that in so doing we may receive far more than we have offered.

So may God show us all the more how to give and receive this two-way welcome, this gracious and merciful and wondrous gift that embodies God’s love in our world, so that all people might know the fullness of God’s love each and every day. Thanks be to God! Amen.

Learning a New Way

June 22, 2014 By Andy James

a sermon on Genesis 21:8-21
preached on June 22, 2014, at the First Presbyterian Church of Whitestone

Fifty years ago yesterday, three young men were murdered about an hour from the town where I grew up in Mississippi. James Chaney, Michael Schwerner, and Andrew Goodman had converged on Philadelphia, Mississippi, from their different backgrounds of rural Mississippi and New York City as part of a summer-long attempt in the Civil Rights Movement to bring attention to and relief from the oppression faced by African-Americans there. In the course of this three-month campaign, thousands of women and men from Mississippi and beyond, with varied racial, ethnic, and religious backgrounds, worked to register voters, integrate public accommodations, initiate educational campaigns, and build a lasting network of leadership to confront the racism and violence that were the norm in Mississippi and throughout the South. These three volunteers Chaney, Schwerner, and Goodman confronted a world that had been so very carefully taught the hate and fear that resulted in their brutal murders at the hands of men who would not face true justice for over forty years.

I can’t help but think about how we teach one another this kind of hate and fear when I hear this morning’s reading from the book of Genesis. Here we see one of the earliest biblical witnesses to oppression based at least in part on cultural difference like that which was confronted in that Freedom Summer fifty years ago. On the day of the celebration of her son Isaac’s weaning, Sarah was furious to see her long-awaited son, a true gift from God in her advanced age, out playing with her husband’s son by their Egyptian slavewoman Hagar. This was simply unacceptable to her. No other child could threaten her son’s place in the line of inheritance, and especially not the child of an Egyptian slave.

So Sarah went to Abraham and demanded that he cast out Hagar and her son Ishmael from his household. Abraham didn’t like the idea all that much, but after consulting with God, he acceded to her plan, trusting God’s promise that both his sons would make a great nation and that even if he cast Hagar and Ishmael out, God would care for them. So Abraham gave them some bread and water and sent Hagar and Ishmael away to wander in the wilderness. But soon their supplies ran out, and Hagar was ready to give up. She couldn’t bear to see her beloved son die, so she left him under a bush and walked away so that she would not have to be a witness to such a horrible sight. She stayed near enough that she could hear his cries, but she could do nothing more than wait for them to go silent.

Yet when Hagar could not answer, God did. God heard Ishmael’s cries and sent an angel to his mother. As is so often the message in such moments in the Bible, the angel told her, “Do not be afraid.” God would take care of the boy. There was more to their story than just their being cast out—they would not only survive, but they would be brought into God’s family all the more, and a great nation would emerge from them, too. God would overcome the hate and fear that led to their being cast out and lead them through the wilderness to new life.

The careful teachings of hate and fear in our world are not limited to Broadway musicals, the state of Mississippi in 1964, or even the world of the Bible—they are sadly still very much present with us today. These teachings in word and action, intentional and unintentional, continue to tell our world that our racism is okay so long as we have a few friends who look different from us, that poverty is not really something for the prosperous to be concerned about, that peace is an unrealistic goal in our world and so we should not feel bad about profiting from war, that injustice may not always need to be answered, let alone remedied, even that hate is permissible so long as it can be backed up with a good reason.

God’s actions with Hagar and Ishmael are among the earliest of many biblical stories that suggest that God offers something more than an endorsement of our own hates and fears. When we judge someone based on her origins, God insists that all are welcome. When we try to justify poverty and perpetuate hardship, God sends surprising provision. When we live in a way of war, God sends a surprising pathway of peace. When we allow injustice to go unquestioned, God questions us. And when we bring hatred of any sort to our interactions with others, God calls us to account for our actions.

It was a privilege to be even a small supporting part of challenging the hate and fear of our world at our denomination’s General Assembly this past week. This biennial gathering of Presbyterians from around the country spoke out against war and injustice and took steps toward a new and different way of peace in the world. While the mainstream media has lifted up two of the assembly’s actions, divesting from three companies whose products support Israel’s occupation of Palestine and giving ministers permission to officiate at same-gender marriages, as I look over the total sweep of its work I see a strange but wonderful embodiment of the kind of love and presence that God showed with Hagar in the General Assembly’s actions.

The assembly spoke out loudly against racism by taking the next step toward including the Belhar Confession from South Africa in our Book of Confessions, and we will use a portion of it in our worship later today. The assembly stood for a true and just peace in the Middle East by divesting Presbyterian holdings from companies who profit from war and human rights abuses in the conflict between Israel and Palestine. The assembly urged Presbyterian congregations across the country to make churches gun-free zones and and to encourage legislators to take meaningful action to reduce gun violence. And the assembly pointed out countless other places where our care and concern as Christians can embody a promise like the one God offered to Hagar and Ishmael, whether it be for LGBT persons who face persecution, prosecution, and sometimes even execution in other countries, for farm workers who are not compensated fairly for their labor, even in some offerings for a church that is wandering in the wilderness and needs a new way of understanding God’s call to us in a changing age.

While good and reasonable and faithful people may agree or disagree with any or all of these actions as we even saw at the assembly, I believe that God calls us continually to set aside the hate and fear that we are taught, the hate and fear that manage to creep into our lives and our world despite our best efforts, the hate and fear that make us and others less than the beloved children of God that we are. And in setting these things aside, I believe that God calls us to learn and teach a new and different way that seeks the well-being of all people and all creation, that stands up and speaks out for the marginalized and oppressed, and that embodies God’s own presence in times of injustice and despair.

These are not easy things to do. It is not easy to set aside some of the things that we have been taught, but as we learn something new, I pray that we will see the depth and breadth and wonder of God’s amazing love for others and ourselves as we seek to live it out in our lives each and every day. So may God teach us carefully how not to hate, how to set aside our fear, and how to live out God’s presence and love each and every day until all things are made new in Jesus Christ our Lord. Lord, come quickly! Amen.

Be Careful What You Pray For

June 8, 2014 By Andy James

a sermon on Acts 2:1-21
preached on Pentecost, June 8, 2014, at the First Presbyterian Church of Whitestone

As I mentioned last Sunday, I spent three days last month with about 500 Lutherans from all across downstate New York, serving as the parliamentarian for their Synod Assembly. The theme for the three-day gathering was “Come Holy Spirit,” which seemed quite appropriate at so many levels. It was only a week before Pentecost, after all, and some of the business was also the sort of thing when you might want the Holy Spirit to be present. At the assembly, they were continuing to live into their Strategic Plan that was adopted last year, and this year they were electing a bishop for a six-year term.

In many ways, the Spirit cooperated perfectly, as the basic business of ministry and operations went off without a hitch, and the strategic plan presentation was great, but when it got to the election of a bishop, the Holy Spirit’s work started to get a little weird. Thankfully they had invested in an electronic voting system to make votes go more quickly, but the first ballot had to be done on paper, and the counters reported that there were 425 ballots cast—when the report from registration showed only 420 voting members! In the end, after an evening of rethinking voting processes and recounting registration sheets, the repeat of the ballot the next morning went off without a hitch, but it was very clear that their prayers of “Come Holy Spirit” were being answered in ways that they didn’t quite expect, and they learned one of the most important lessons about the Holy Spirit: be careful what you pray for!

The first Pentecost as told in our reading this morning from Acts had its own surprising and unexpected turns, too. The disciples had been spending time together in Jerusalem after Jesus’ resurrection and ascension, waiting and watching for whatever would come next, praying for the Holy Spirit to come as Jesus had promised them. However, I doubt that they expected the Spirit to show up quite like it did, with a rush of wind blowing through the room, divided tongues of fire settling on each of them, and the strange gift of speaking and being understood in the languages of the world coming up the disciples just in time to speak to faithful Jews from around the world who had gathered in Jerusalem to celebrate the festival now known as Shavuot.

Once again, the Spirit had shown up, and things got weird. Everyone in the city was astonished, for they could tell that the people who were speaking in these languages were ordinary folks from Galilee—a region that everyone considered to be the backwater of the backwaters of the Roman empire. But it wasn’t just that—the message was strange and surprising too, describing the good news of God’s deeds of power and mercy in this man named Jesus.

Everyone was trying to figure out what was going on. Some were genuinely curious, others a touch perplexed, and still others completely dismissive, fully convinced that the only thing special going on here was an abundant serving of wine with breakfast! But the Spirit had shown up in ways beyond their expectations, offering an amazing and surprising appearance of power on that first day of Pentecost and inspiring the first disciples to expand their community as they welcomed the first group of newcomers to join their circle after Jesus’ death, resurrection, and ascension. But the Spirit’s surprising power made it clear that they had to be careful what they prayed for.

The Holy Spirit whose coming we celebrate today is a strange and unexpected presence in our lives and our world, and as these stories show, we too have to be careful what we pray for when we pray “Come Holy Spirit.” This Spirit comes in unexpected times and places, challenging our assumptions about what God is up to in our world, insisting that we think again about the plans we have laid out for ourselves, demanding that we open our hearts to something other than the status quo or the easiest and most comfortable and familiar option. This Spirit comes and challenges our assumptions, popping into our lives with surprising displays of power and presence that often raise as many questions as answers, suggesting that we might need to look for God at work in new and different ways, and defeating all our attempts at controlling its power in our world. And this Spirit comes with a presence that sometimes looks nothing less than weird, upsetting our our attempts at good process, surprising us with unexpected outcomes, and guiding us into a new and different way. Yet through it all, the Holy Spirit is among us, coming into our lives in amazing and wonderful ways to show us the presence of God each and every day.

My friends, there are two places where I think we need to be on the lookout for this strange and amazing Spirit in the coming days, especially praying “Come Holy Spirit” in our lives and our world. First, I hope that you will join me in praying for the Spirit’s presence at our Presbyterian General Assembly that begins next Saturday in Detroit. There, about 700 ruling and teaching elders from across the country will gather to discern the call of the Holy Spirit in the life of our national church. I’ll be going myself in my role as Stated Clerk of the Presbytery of New York City, though I’m there to support and advise our four commissioners and won’t be able to speak or vote. This 221st gathering of our national church will be working to discern the Spirit’s call among us on issues ranging from procedural changes in our Book of Order to divestment from companies that profit from the use of fossil fuels or non-peaceful pursuits in Israeli-occupied territories to same-gender marriage in our church and everything in between.

While I suspect a lot of the voting commissioners will go to Detroit with ideas and thoughts about the issues before the assembly, our common understanding as Presbyterians is that they gather with that prayer of “Come Holy Spirit,” not representing the view of the people in the pews or the pulpits but coming together by the power of the Spirit for this one week to discern God’s call to the church in these days. While this simple prayer of “Come Holy Spirit” may not embody our clear expectations and wishes for particular outcomes in these deliberations, I believe that this simple prayer is the best thing we can offer this important gathering as we trust that God’s presence will inspire these faithful women and men as they find and seek the will of God together, even if it makes us wish we had been more careful about what we prayed for!

The second place where today we will pray “Come Holy Spirit” is a little closer to home. Today as we welcome our confirmation class into membership of this congregation and two of them receive the sacrament of baptism, this my prayer for each of them, that the Holy Spirit might be present with Nicholas, Avayana, Chris, and Christine as they continue to grow in their faith in this place and beyond. Again, we don’t know exactly what that prayer will bring them, but we offer it anyway, trusting that the gift of the Holy Spirit—even if it ends up being a bit weird!—will be enough to sustain them as they walk the road ahead and join us in the journey of following Jesus each and every day.

So while we may wish that we had been more careful about what we prayed for when we pray “Come Holy Spirit,” may we always trust that the Spirit will come and surprise us and astonish us and challenge us whether we want it or not, inspiring us to pray with all the more confidence and hope, “Come Holy Spirit,” so that we all might be filled with the power and wonder of this amazing gift on this day of Pentecost and every day of this journey of faith together. Thanks be to God! Amen.